kalleah: (critic)
[personal profile] kalleah
I'll cut everything except my excessive relief at finally having seen it.  :)

Hmm.

I think I liked it, but I'm not entirely sure.  Let me mull over my response in handy bulleted format.

  • WTF was with the creepy chibi!Doctor?  I felt the overwhelming urge to smack Uncle Rusty on the snout with a rolled up newspaper and say "no" in a firm voice.
  • John Simm was wonderful although not as cool as the last episode ... but really, he so completely rocked in the last one that I can't fault him for that.
  • WTF with Lucy?  I got that she went batty, but why shoot him?  I mean, someone clearly needed to.  The Master as the Doctor's pet in the TARDIS is too squicky for words.  Now, there's a case to be made for Doctor/Master.  I'm not entirely opposed to that, either, but it seems like keeping the Master caged up in the TARDIS is a lot like what the Master did to him.
  • I loved, loved, loved the Master's death scene.  Tennant is a superb actor and I just ached for him being all alone, again.
  • Yes, the funeral pyre was a little Return of the Jedi.  No Ewoks though.  Look on the bright side.
  • The woman's hand picking up the ring was a little wrinkly.  I don't think it's Lucy.
  • I do love how they undid the Toclafane's arrival and still had Martha et all remembering what happened.  It would be a damn shame for the Joneses and Jack to go through that and then just forget.  The population of the Earth?  As usual, better off not knowing.
  • Jack as the Face of Boe?  WTF?  (I seem to be saying that a fair bit.)  One assumes that as a time traveler that he'd have heard of the Face of Boe.  Seems like a weird thing for him to toss out then, but I guess it does answer the "does Jack die" question.  He dies in the year five billion as a big head in a jar with no penis.  (One assumes.)  I suspect for Jack, the whole lack of a penis thing is more awful than the whole unable to die thing.
  • The Doctor invited Jack along.  Yay.  And of course he messed with the vortex manipulator.  He had to.
  • Rose moment.  The Doctor didn't say "second best to whom?" either.  He's just rude enough to say that, too, if he didn't already know.
  • The HMS Titanic busts through the wall of the TARDIS?  I guess a really big-ass boat is stronger than the assembled hordes of Genghis Khan.
I want to watch the Confidential, but I can at least get through for a day or so until I do so.

Date: 2007-07-01 09:43 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] beck-liz.livejournal.com
Also, why didn't the Doctor pick up on Boe's being a "Fact"?

I don't follow. ?


The Doctor could feel that Jack was wrong because he was a Fact and ran away. So why didn't he feel the same wrongness from Boe?

Date: 2007-07-01 08:48 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] kalleah.livejournal.com
The Doctor could feel that Jack was wrong because he was a Fact and ran away.

Ah, I gotcha. That is an excellent question. Maybe because by that point, Jack/Boe were evolving, changing, moving on. After all, we did see him die.

Profile

kalleah: (Default)
kalleah

September 2012

S M T W T F S
      1
2345678
910 1112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30      

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 9th, 2025 08:55 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios